Parts Markup vs Margin: How to Price Garage Parts
Markup and margin on parts explained with one example, a conversion table, the mistake that costs money, rounding, tax and updating prices when costs change.
Fatih Bilgiç · · 7 min read
“I put thirty percent on parts” and “I make thirty percent on parts” sound like the same sentence. They are not, and the gap between them is money that many workshops believe they earn and never see. The first sentence describes a markup, the second a margin. This guide explains the difference with one part and two numbers, gives you a small conversion table, and shows how to set parts prices so that the percentage in your head matches the one in your reports. The figures are examples for the arithmetic, not recommendations: which percentage is right depends on your costs and your market.
Markup and margin: two ways to describe the same profit
Both numbers start from the same profit: selling price minus cost. They divide it by different things.
- Markup is the profit as a percentage of the cost. It answers: “How much do I add to what I paid?”
- Margin is the profit as a percentage of the selling price. It answers: “How much of what the customer pays stays with me?”
Markup looks from the purchase side, margin from the sales side. Because the selling price is always higher than the cost, the margin is always the smaller number for the same part.
One part, two numbers
You buy a part for 100 and sell it for 130, both without tax. The profit is 30.
- Markup: 30 ÷ 100 = 30 percent.
- Margin: 30 ÷ 130 = 23.08 percent.
The same part, the same profit, and two correct answers. The formulas to move between them:
- Margin = markup ÷ (100 + markup) × 100
- Markup = margin ÷ (100 − margin) × 100
| Markup on cost | Selling price for a cost of 100 | Margin on selling price |
|---|---|---|
| 20% | 120 | 16.67% |
| 25% | 125 | 20% |
| 30% | 130 | 23.08% |
| 50% | 150 | 33.33% |
| 100% | 200 | 50% |
The mix-up that costs money
The trouble starts when a target is set as a margin and the price is calculated as a markup. Suppose you have worked out that parts must leave 30 percent of their selling price to cover your costs. At the counter, someone takes the cost of 100 and adds 30 percent: 130.
To keep 30 percent of the selling price, the part has to be sold at 100 ÷ (1 − 0.30) = 142.86. The markup that produces a 30 percent margin is 42.86 percent, not 30. On a single part the difference is 12.86. Across a year’s parts purchases it is the difference between the plan and the bank balance.
The same trap exists for discounts. A 10 percent discount on a part priced at 130 takes 13 off the price, and that 13 comes entirely out of the 30 of profit. The discount sounded like a tenth; it cost more than two fifths of what you earned on that part.
Which one should you use?
Use both, each for its own job, and never leave the word out:
- Markup for setting prices. You know the cost when the part arrives; multiplying it is the natural way to get a selling price.
- Margin for reading results. Reports start from sales. “What share of parts revenue is profit?” is a margin question.
If you set a labor rate as well, the same logic applies there; our guide on how to set your garage labor rate uses the margin formula to add profit to the break-even rate.
One markup does not fit every part
A single percentage for the whole shelf is easy to remember and wrong at both ends. A fuse bought for very little cannot carry its share of ordering, storing and handling with 30 percent; a turbocharger with the same 30 percent may end up priced above what the customer can find elsewhere in a minute. Most workshops therefore work with a few rules instead of one number:
- By cost range: a higher markup on cheap parts, a lower one on expensive parts.
- By category: fast-moving service items such as filters and wiper blades separate from slow, bulky parts.
- By brand: where a supplier’s conditions or the competition differ.
- By exception: a few products with their own percentage, because you know them.
In Baktam the profit percentage is a markup on cost: selling price = cost × (1 + profit % ÷ 100). You can set a default percentage for the business, rules by brand, category and cost range, and a percentage of its own on a single product. For each product the most specific setting wins: the product’s own percentage first, then the first matching rule, then the default. On the product form, cost, profit percentage and selling price are linked, so typing one shows the others.
Rounding and tax
Calculated prices are rarely pretty: 100 × 1.4286 is 142.86, and nobody wants that figure on a quote. Round in a fixed way so that two people at the counter get the same price. Common choices are the nearest whole number, the nearest 5 or 10, or prices that end in 9. In Baktam you pick one of these once and it is applied to every calculated price; you can also leave prices unrounded.
Do the calculation without tax. Cost is the price you paid without tax, and the markup is applied to that. If you show prices including tax to customers, the rounding should apply to the amount they see, with tax added first.
When your supplier changes prices
A markup only protects you if the cost behind it is current. When a supplier raises prices and your selling prices stay where they were, your markup shrinks without anyone deciding it. Two habits prevent that:
- Update costs when the delivery is booked in, not at the end of the year.
- Reprice in bulk, not part by part. Select a category, a brand or the whole list, look at a preview of old and new prices, then apply.
Baktam’s bulk price update works this way: preview first, then apply, and an undo if the result is not what you wanted. You can apply your rules, set one fixed percentage, or raise current selling prices by a percentage. For products where you switch it on, the selling price is recalculated automatically when the cost changes; this is off by default, so prices never move silently. Cost and profit percentages are visible to the owner and managers only, not to technicians or cashiers. How parts, deliveries and stock levels are handled is on the stock management page and in our garage stock management guide.
Common mistakes
- Saying “percent” without saying of what. Agree in the workshop that prices are set with a markup on cost and results are read as a margin on sales.
- Calculating on the price including tax. The tax is not yours; leave it out of both cost and selling price.
- Forgetting freight and small costs. If delivery is charged separately, it belongs in the cost of the part.
- Old costs in the system. A markup on last year’s purchase price is a discount on today’s.
- Discounts given in markup thinking. Check what a discount does to the profit, not to the price.
Prices, stock and job cards belong together: the part you price is the part that goes onto the job. Our garage management software page shows how they connect.